Introduction:

It was early August 2025, and the team at Teejh Jewellery was staring at their Instagram analytics in disbelief. Their Stories—once the crown jewel of their social media strategy—were struggling. Swipe-ups had plummeted, sticker taps were half of what they used to be, and engagement felt like it had evaporated overnight. For a brand that had built its identity around emotional storytelling and connecting with Indian audiences, this was a shock. The question haunting the team: “What’s changed in Instagram Stories engagement in 2025?”

This wasn’t just a numbers problem—it was a human one. Stories had always been Teejh’s way to celebrate relationships, like the brother-sister bond during Raksha Bandhan, a campaign that previously went viral across India. Now, those same stories barely resonated. But in adversity lay opportunity. Understanding the Instagram Stories algorithm, evolving user behavior, and strategically leveraging UGC videos became the brand’s lifeline. Today, their journey stands as a blueprint for Indian brands navigating Instagram’s complex 2025 landscape.

1. The Awakening: Understanding Instagram Stories Engagement in 2025

For years, Teejh Jewellery relied on bright, product-focused Stories. They assumed a beautiful photo or video was enough. But Instagram’s 2025 update changed everything. The platform began prioritizing meaningful interactions over passive impressions. Views alone no longer guaranteed reach. Every poll tap, emoji slider, reply, or share mattered. The brand had to face a simple truth: Instagram Stories engagement now measured authenticity and relatability above all else.

Indian audiences had grown savvier. They craved stories that made them feel seen, not sold to. Teejh realized that their engagement issues weren’t because of the products—they were due to the way the stories were told. It was no longer about showcasing jewellery; it was about connecting emotionally. In the words of their social media head, “Our audience wanted to participate in the story, not just watch it unfold.”

1.1 Defining Engagement in a Shifting Landscape

By mid-2025, engagement wasn’t just a vanity metric—it had become the heartbeat of the campaign. Teejh studied Instagram Stories changes 2025 meticulously. Metrics such as:

• Completion Rate: Did viewers watch the story till the end?
• Sticker Taps: Did users interact with polls, quizzes, or emoji sliders?
• Replies and Shares: Were viewers compelled to respond or forward content?
• Forward/Backward Swipes: Did the content intrigue enough for repeat views?

Each data point painted a picture: Instagram no longer rewarded passive consumption. Meaningful interactions dictated reach. Brands leveraging platforms like Hobo.Video could analyze these metrics efficiently, revealing patterns invisible to standard analytics. This allowed Teejh to pivot, emphasizing storytelling that prompted real action.

1.2 When Numbers Tell a Story

A deep dive into the data revealed alarming trends. The Instagram Stories reach drop reasons were clear: audience saturation, algorithmic changes, and a lack of interactive elements. While traditional content maintained modest viewership, interactive and emotionally resonant content consistently outperformed.

During the pre-Raksha Bandhan campaign, Teejh experimented with UGC videos featuring real siblings. Each clip wasn’t just promotional—it told a story of care, nostalgia, and celebration. The results? Engagement skyrocketed. Completion rates jumped 35%, sticker taps increased 28%, and shares nearly doubled. This was proof thathow Instagram Stories engagement works in 2025 had shifted: authenticity and participation now drove visibility.

2. The Storm: Algorithm Changes and Their Impact

Instagram’s 2025 algorithm changes felt like a storm to brands unprepared for it. Teejh, however, saw it as a challenge. The algorithm now prioritized stories that created conversations, not just views. Interactive elements and genuine participation became the currency of engagement.

2.1 Algorithm Updates Affecting Reach

Stories that inspired replies, poll participation, or sticker interactions were favored. Static promotional posts, even if visually stunning, fell in priority. Reports showed that accounts integrating interactive storytelling saw up to 25% higher reach than those relying solely on static visuals. For Teejh, embracing these insights was the first step toward reclaiming audience attention.

2.2 Decoding Story Performance Metrics

The brand discovered that metrics like shares, sticker taps, and completion rates had become the new indicators of success. Even average view counts, once a pride point, became secondary. Leveraging AI influencer marketing and UGC videos allowed Teejh to design stories that resonated deeply while remaining measurable. Their platform of choice, Hobo.Video, offered insights on which type of content performed best, down to which sticker placement encouraged the highest interaction.

3. The Turning Point: Embracing UGC andInfluencer Marketing

Recognizing the algorithmic shifts was only part of the solution. Teejh needed human stories—real, relatable narratives that resonated with audiences. They launched a Raksha Bandhan campaign involving real sibling stories, integrating famous Instagram influencers and UGC videos.

3.1 The Power of Real Stories

Instead of just showcasing jewellery, Teejh invited users to share personal stories of sibling bonds. These user-generated clips created authentic emotional connections. Polls and emoji sliders asked viewers: “Which sibling moment melts your heart?” Engagement surged. The campaign became a blueprint in India for connecting emotionally while staying algorithm-friendly.

3.2 Influencer Partnerships Amplify Reach

Working with top influencers in India ensured the campaign reached broader audiences. Influencers shared their personal stories, blending authenticity with storytelling. Hobo.Video’s AI-powered insights identified the influencers whose audiences were most likely to engage, optimizing reach and performance. By combining AI analytics with human creativity, Teejh transformed its Instagram Stories engagement trajectory dramatically.

3.3 Metrics That Mattered

The results were tangible:

• Completion Rate: Up 35%
• Sticker Taps: Up 28%
• Shares: Doubled
• Follower Engagement: Increased by 22%

This success demonstrated the full truth of Instagram Stories engagement in 2025: emotion, participation, and authenticity now determine performance.

4. Mastering Instagram Stories Engagement: The Teejh Strategy

After their awakening, the Teejh team understood one crucial fact: numbers alone don’t tell the story—Stories themselves must tell a story. The brand’s 2025 pivot focused on crafting narratives that compelled interaction, blending UGC videos, influencer campaigns, and algorithm-friendly strategies.

For example, during Raksha Bandhan, Teejh launched a campaign inviting siblings to share heartfelt memories using the hashtag #TeejhBond. Every submission became part of their Instagram Stories, showcasing real emotion. Polls and emoji sliders invited the audience to vote on moments they related to most. This strategy transformed passive viewers into active participants, dramatically increasing Instagram Stories engagement in 2025.

Platforms likeHobo.Videobecame indispensable. By analyzing viewer behavior, sticker interactions, and completion rates, the team could identify which stories resonated the most. AI-driven insights helped prioritize influencer content and UGC submissions that drove the highest engagement. The result? A seamless blend of authenticity, strategy, and storytelling that captured attention in an algorithm-driven world.

4.1 Creating Emotional Storytelling That Resonates

The Teejh campaign proved that storytelling is the heartbeat of modern Instagram success. Audiences now crave emotion over aesthetics. Every Story had a narrative arc: introduce emotion → invite participation → reward interaction. For instance, one Story featured a sibling opening a gift with tears in their eyes, followed by a poll asking viewers about their own experiences.

The emotional resonance wasn’t accidental. Data shows that interactive and emotionally-driven Stories outperform static promotional content by 40–50% in 2025. By focusing on shared human experiences, Teejh transformed Stories into an emotional journey rather than just a marketing channel. This is the exact essence of how Instagram Stories engagement works in 2025—creating content that audiences want to feel part of.

4.2 Leveraging Influencers and AI Insights

Partnering with famous Instagram influencers amplified Teejh’s reach. Influencers shared their sibling stories, providing authenticity and relatability. Hobo.Video’s AI algorithms identified influencers whose followers were likely to engage, optimizing story placement and timing.

The results were astounding:

• Influencer-led UGC Stories boosted completion rates by 35%
• Sticker interactions increased 28%
• Shares and saves doubled
• Followers increased their average daily engagement by 22%

This demonstrated the full truth of AI influencer marketing in India: combining emotional storytelling with analytical insight ensures content reaches the right audience at the right time.

5. Practical Steps to Boost Instagram Stories Engagement in 2025

Teejh’s success provides a blueprint for other Indian brands. Here’s a step-by-step framework:

5.1 Optimize for the Algorithm

• Prioritize interactive stickers like polls, quizzes, and emoji sliders
• Use videos over static images
• Post consistently during peak hours
• Avoid overly promotional content

5.2 Harness UGC for Authenticity

• Invite followers to share stories related to your brand
• Curate the best submissions into Stories campaigns
• Reward participation with shoutouts or small incentives

5.3 Collaborate with Top Influencers

• Partner with top influencers in India whose audiences align with your brand
• Let influencers share personal narratives
• Combine human creativity with AI insights from platforms like Hobo.Video

5.4 Track Metrics and Iterate

• Monitor completion rates, sticker taps, replies, shares, and forward/backward swipes
• Adjust content based on engagement patterns
• Use AI-driven dashboards to identify what resonates best

By combining these tactics, brands can turn Instagram Stories into a powerful storytelling engine, driving engagement in 2025 and beyond.

6. Lessons Learned From Teejh Jewellery

Teejh’s journey offers valuable insights:

1. Authenticity is non-negotiable: Audiences ignore content that doesn’t feel real.
2. Emotion drives engagement: Stories that evoke nostalgia, love, or joy perform best.
3. Interactive features are essential: Polls, quizzes, and emoji sliders directly influence reach.
4. UGC is powerful: Real customer stories boost credibility and engagement.
5. Influencers amplify authenticity: Carefully selected influencers provide reach and relatability.
6. AI insights optimize strategy: Platforms like Hobo.Video make data-driven storytelling possible.

9. About Hobo.Video

Hobo.Videois India’s leading AI-powered influencer marketing and UGC company. With over 2.25 million creators, it offers end-to-end campaign management designed for brand growth. The platform combines AI and human strategy for maximum ROI.

Services include:

• Influencer marketing
• UGC content creation
• Celebrity endorsements
• Product feedback and testing
• Marketplace and seller reputation management
• Regional and niche influencer campaigns

Trusted by top brands like Himalaya, Wipro, Symphony, Baidyanath, and the Good Glamm Group, Hobo.Video ensures every campaign drives authentic engagement and measurable results.

Need a Strategy plan that actually works for your brand?Let’s build it together.
Influencers thrive in the right space — this is one of them.Get started.