Introduction: The Content Format Battle in 2025

Reels, Shorts, or Carousels? That’s the burning question creators and brands are asking in 2025. With short-form video surging, creators must constantly choose between Instagram Reels, YouTube Shorts, and static or swipeable formats like carousels. But which one truly performs the best?

To find the answer, Hobo.Video surveyed over 2,000 creators across India—from top influencers in India to emerging nano creators. The goal: decode real preferences and performance outcomes around Reels, Shorts, or Carousels?

1. Short-Form Video in 2025: Why It Still Reigns

1.1 The Swipe Culture Is Here to Stay

More than 82% of surveyed creators agreed that short-form video content 2025 is non-negotiable. Platforms like Instagram, YouTube, and even Pinterest now prioritize videos under 60 seconds for discovery.

Data shows Reels and Shorts generate 3x more reach than static posts. But it’s not just about reach—it’s about action. Reels, for instance, drive 56% more saves and 33% more shares on average.

According to Meta India, Instagram Reels consumption jumped 37% YoY in Tier-2 and Tier-3 cities in 2024.

1.2 YouTube Shorts vs TikTok Videos: Where Does India Lean?

While TikTok remains banned, Indian creators are doubling down on YouTube Shorts. Nearly 49% of full-time influencers use Shorts weekly compared to 68% using Instagram Reels.

Brands, however, report higher conversion from Reels due to integrated shopping, strong UGC, and native influencer culture.

Amplify Your Brand,
One Influence at a Time.

Connect with an Expert

2. Instagram Reels vs Carousels: What’s Working Now

2.1 Reels for Reach, Carousels for Retention

Instagram Reels remain king for reach. However, when it comes to saves, comments, and click-throughs, Carousel post performance 2025 tells another story. Carousels, especially step-by-step tutorials or “the influencer” storytelling formats, generate 2.6x more engagement.

This is crucial for brands that rely on educational content or feature-rich products.

2.2 Creator Sentiment Around Each Format

From our survey, creators responded:

• 61% prefer Reels for fast growth
• 24% favor carousels for higher-quality audience
• 15% use Shorts for brand diversification

This reflects the duality: Instagram Reels engagement rate brings followers, while carousels convert them.

3. How Brands Choose the Best Performing Format on Social Media

3.1 Campaign Objective Drives Format Choice

Want reach? Use Reels. Want storytelling? Go with Carousels. Want platform crossover? Consider Shorts. Hobo.Video’s data from 250 campaigns shows this pattern:

• Reels led to a 41% rise in impressions
• Carousels drove 29% more saves
• Shorts got 22% higher YouTube click-throughs

Each format works—but only when aligned with intent.

3.2 The Rise of UGC Videos in All Formats

UGC videos are being embedded into Reels and Shorts more than ever. Real people, real voices, no filters—that’s the new creator brief. D2C skincare brand “The Whole Truth” saw 4.5x ROI with regional UGC-driven Reels in 2024. That trend continues this year.

4. Format Breakdown: Reels, Shorts, or Carousels?

4.1 Instagram Reels Popularity

Still the go-to for Indian creators. Features like remix, music integration, and native shopping make Reels versatile. Reels rank #1 in discovery and are being pushed more by Instagram’s algorithm.

4.2 YouTube Shorts

Shorts are favored by creators expanding into long-form. It works well for tech, education, and fitness niches where YouTube already dominates. Shorts also offer better monetization and long-term visibility compared to Reels.

4.3 Carousel Posts Engagement 2025

Carousel posts still thrive in niche categories. Fashion, food, and skincare creators say carousels bring the highest saves. Multiple frames allow for storytelling, product breakdowns, and detailed reviews—ideal for influencer marketing India campaigns.

5. Creator Insights: What They Really Think

5.1 Famous Instagram Influencers Speak

“Carousels helped me retain a loyal audience while Reels grew my numbers.” – Tanya Mehta (@styleverse.in, 210K followers)

“For tech explainer content, Shorts outperformed Reels. YouTube’s algorithm has longer recall.” – Harshit Taneja (@bytehack, 89K subscribers)

“My highest-converting format is UGC in Reels with a ‘How to’ approach.” – Amrita Nair (@beautydecoded, 120K followers)

6. Strategic Tips: How to Choose the Right Format

6.1 Know Where Your Audience Is

Not every format suits every niche. Fashion, beauty, and lifestyle dominate Reels. Tech and finance thrive on Shorts. Carousel posts work best for tutorial-driven content.

6.2 Combine Formats Strategically

Post a Reel to draw attention. Follow it with a carousel that adds depth. Repurpose both for Shorts to reach new YouTube audiences.

6.3 Use AI UGC Wisely

With AI influencer marketing tools like those from Hobo.Video, brands are combining performance data with human storytelling. Use AI to test thumbnails, captions, and timing—but never remove the creator’s authenticity.

7. Hobo.Video Platform Insights

7.1 What Is the Best Influencer Platform Doing?

Hobo.Video isn’t just connecting brands to creators. It offers analytics, AI UGC integration, and format-level performance tracking.

Over 2.25 million creators now use Hobo.Video to learn how to become an influencer, find collaborations, and optimize performance.

7.2 Why Hobo.Video Works

Because it blends data with storytelling. As the top influencer marketing company, it’s helping brands move beyond trends into tactics.

8. Conclusion: What We Learned About Reels, Shorts, or Carousels?

Summary: Choosing the Right Format

• Use Reels for quick reach and trending appeal
• Post Shorts for long-term visibility and platform expansion
• Use Carousels for storytelling and deeper saves
• Integrate UGC videos in every format
• Choose based on campaign intent—not popularity

Creators across India trust what’s working, not what’s shiny. From fashion to fintech, the format must fit the story.

Whether you’re using Reels, Shorts, or Carousels?, ensure it aligns with your audience and purpose.

About Hobo.Video

Hobo.Video is India’s leading AI-powered influencer marketing and UGC company. With over 2.25 million creators, it offers end-to-end campaign management designed for brand growth. The platform combines AI and human strategy for maximum ROI.

Services include:

• Influencer marketing
• UGC content creation
• Celebrity endorsements
• Product feedback and testing
• Marketplace and seller reputation management
• Regional and niche influencer campaigns

Trusted by top brands like Himalaya, Wipro, Symphony, Baidyanath and the Good Glamm Group.